Agentic AI for Marketing: Hype vs. Reality

"Agentic AI" is the buzzword everyone's throwing around in 2026. The promise is AI that doesn't just answer questions but autonomously executes multi-step tasks. The reality for small marketing teams is a bit more complicated than Silicon Valley would like you to believe, though.

Bright graphic with a target, analytics charts, arrows, and marketing labels showing AI-driven campaign performance and growth.

What agentic AI actually means

Instead of you telling AI to write an email, agentic AI supposedly finds the contact, drafts the message, schedules it, and follows up without you having to touch it.

For enterprise companies with massive marketing operations, this is apparently the next big thing. Early adopters claim 3x ROI improvements and significant cost savings. The agentic AI market is expected to grow from $7.55 billion in 2025 to nearly $200 billion by 2034.

Impressive numbers, and it's clearly big business. But the problem is that very little of that applies to teams like ours.

Why complex automation doesn't work at our scale

We're a small marketing agency working with B2B IT companies. Our projects are custom, our clients are specific, and our timelines change based on real-world factors.

In our case, setting up sophisticated workflow automation takes longer than just doing the task ourselves. And we'd spend more time checking if the automation worked correctly than we would have spent doing it manually.

The people obsessing about agentic AI are solving different problems than we are, at a different scale. They're managing hundreds of campaigns across dozens of markets. We're creating targeted content for specific personas in niche industries.

What actually works: simple, specific automation

With all that being said, there are a few small-scale use cases where the "agentic" concept genuinely helps.

  • Browser research synthesis: Point AI at multiple sources, get a coherent summary. That's technically "agentic": it autonomously processes multiple inputs. And it saves real time. Check out our dedicated blog on AI browsers for more info.
  • Social variations from content: Once you've published a blog post, having AI create 5-10 social media posts in different tones is really useful to get a baseline.
  • Meeting transcript insights: After client calls, AI can extract action items, key decisions, and recurring themes. We still need to review it, but it's faster than manual note taking.
  • Competitive intelligence summaries: Point AI at your competitors' latest content. Get a synthesis of their positioning and messaging themes. Then apply your human judgement about what it means.

Notice the pattern? These are all cases where AI does mechanical synthesis, not strategic thinking.

Dark green quotation marks.

At our scale, setting up automation takes more time than just doing the work. That's not efficiency, that's procrastination with extra steps.

Marketing automation tools we're watching (but not using yet)

Tools like n8n (open-source workflow automation) and Zapier (the more user-friendly option) are on our radar for connecting different tools together.

But we're cautious. Very cautious.

The temptation with these tools is to automate everything. Connect your CRM to your email tool, to your social scheduler, to your analytics platform, to just about anything. Build elaborate workflows that trigger based on complex conditions.

And then spend three hours debugging why the automation didn't fire or checking every output because you're not quite sure if it worked correctly.

For now, we're sticking with manual processes we understand over automated processes we have to babysit.

When to actually use AI tools

Our rule of thumb: automate the repetitive stuff that doesn't need your creative input.

Good candidates:

  • Reformatting content for different channels
  • Extracting structured data from unstructured sources
  • Generating variations of approved messaging
  • Pulling together information from multiple places

Bad candidates:

  • Anything requiring strategic judgement
  • Final drafts of client-facing content
  • Decisions about messaging or positioning
  • Tasks where mistakes have real consequences

If the automation saves you 10 minutes, but it takes 20 minutes to set up and 5 minutes to verify, you haven't saved time, you've wasted it.

The bottom line

Agentic AI is real, and it's impressive. For enterprise companies with the scale and resources to implement it properly, it's probably a game-changer. But for small marketing teams working on custom projects with specific clients, the ROI isn't there yet.

We're keeping an eye on it. Maybe in a year or two, the tools will be simple enough and reliable enough that they make sense at our scale. But today, we're focusing on using AI to work faster, not on building complex automation that we have to maintain.

Want to talk about how we use AI practically, without the hype?

Three colleagues having a discussion in a modern meeting room with laptops on the table.

Ready to rumble?

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.